Thursday, September 27, 2007

the great indian SME

"there's been a windfall. i have an additional 17 lac this year. wow. there are a few options. i can use this money to develop a better product, or hire a better team to make better packaging or communication, or forward it to the bank for better working capital facilities or can park a mercedes e class in my garage". surprisingly, in 11 cases out of 10, the chosen alternative is the mercedes. obvious then that daimler is making a killing in this otherwise poor country.

if you don't seem to identify with the above, just change the quantum of money, build better options and end with a better bigger and more expensive car or a jet plane. and you will reach the obvious foregone conclusion. i have talked to dozens of entrepreneurs and seasoned business professionals. who have for years been in a bracket. called SME. have great desire to grow out of the bracket. but somehow don't. and the attitude grows into every sphere of their lives. they assume their product or business process to be unique. or very accomplished. and hence prefer secrecy over transparency. they refuse to see any merit in sharing their wealth, knowledge or process. as a result stagnate and never improve. because improvement happens when you open yourself to new thoughts, ideas and people. they seem to block it in their endeavor to build, sustain or retain competitive advantages or a level of income.

in the closed economy that we were, quite a few of such attitudinally incorrect proprietors became too big. then they discovered the merit of putting money into their pockets through IPOs. thankfully, the economy and the government opened up. competition grew and forced quality, innovation and survival. few who could change or cope with the idea of change benefitted. but most just disappeared into oblivion. or some corner of pricing. and made compromises. somehow resistance got hardwired into genes. and even today i see a curious lot of entrepreneurs tied up in the baggage of the past. some of them have turned their businesses into professional ventures aping best practises from wherever they can get. but when investing into newer projects, get back to the good old rhythm of resistance. and amazingly, this is uniquely indian individuality. remember the story of two indian crabs. maybe that home-grown truth seems to motivate most SMEs.

listen all of you SMEs. even infosys was an SME at some point in time or the other. the promoter kept growing people, skills, ideas and power into the business through open sharing of wealth. while he retains a smaller share, and therefore does not feature amongst the richest indians, i think he has won admiration and merit in the eyes of the millions that make the new india, and not the largely single owner of a competitor, wipro. because, when we think of statesmen presidents, we think of him first. does this example tell you of the merits of sharing? does it inspire you to do so in your life? well, a lot of the entrepreneurs i know did answer that narayan murthy is an inspiration. but somewhow they prefer to retain close to 100% of their equity. and do not hire better people through ESOPs. there exists fear in hiring good people. "if he is smarter than me, would he respect me"? or "wouldn't he learn fast, quit, and do it better than me elsewhere". back to square one.

why do i hate this attitude, this uniquely indian quality, when i am myself a serial entrepreneur. who has failed more often than not. and has never been able to build a steady revenue stream in any of the ventures.

because i think the attitude is tantamount to cheating buyers. that's why. developing a better product is not just a competitive need, but it is a responsibility towards all and any buyers. after all, they are spending really hard earned money in buying your product. you may have positioned your product for the middle class, keeping a very low or reasonable purchase price. but listen, it is that much more hard earned in that income class. the poor buyer must have worked 14 straight hours to earn that miniscule amount, and has chosen to spend it on you. how dare you not be grateful and kind to such a buyer? how dare you force him to make compromises? how dare you cheat him of the value he is paying for?

so what then should an SME do? lets look at the other end first. what is the desired index of quality that i want the SME to incorporate? well, start with the understanding that a buyer is buying your product to solve a problem. it could be a unique, persistent or an evolving problem. your product maybe the entire solution or a part of the solution. else, it definitely is the problem and you are lucky to have come this far. quality is often misunderstood with process quality. process quality is the measure of the output of a production process. if 90% of all output from the process fall within the tolerance limits of engineering, then it is said to be of good quality. but true quality is the ability to innovate and develop better products to solve the said problem. nothing can be more obvious or simpler than this. but understanding this means spending money into research, interpretations, cost function people like R&D, expensive people at front-ends and changes to fixed machines and business processes. at the immediate downside, it looks like one massive dent in the cash flows. but man, just like any other cap-ex, it returns a better yield just around the corner. it too has a break-even period but is still better than compromised profits made in making and selling an inferior product. if you compromise your buyers, sooner than later, they start earning better and ditch you at the first possible instance or opportunity. so even the compromised profits have a life. what will you do after that? also, Mr. Senior Entrepreneur, this is the reason why most of your next generation seems to move towards other investment opportunities. because they see this limited life of the business as you have made it.

and after product development and quality, he should keep bettering the marketing mix to ensure that he delivers more value than he collects in terms of sales price.

but does this mean that you the SME have to forego a lot of cash, increase risk manifold and compromise on your lifestyle simply because i want you to be good to your buyers? firsts, CASH. when you buy a plant worth 50 lacs, you do forego a lot of cash. but there was a projected break-even and some assurance of likely success. similarly in marketing, there is an initial outflow. but sustenace comes at a much lower cost. and being good to buyer always earns you better premiums, word-of-mouth and recommendations. Does this increase risk manifold. I think risk increases manifold when you do not do this. for instance, if you made mattresses (like in the blog page below), then you are bound to gain share by lowering your price or give large seasonal discounts or add incentives to sales. but on the other hand, if you understood the problem of 'good sleep', then probably you would innovate massaging mattresses, gentle music playing mattresses, oxygen spewing mattresses, and other such values that promote good sleep. now imagine, the profits you can make over the next few years simply because you win-over a few but exceedingly loyal spokesperson buyers. and any one of them could be the tipping point you have been waiting for all your life! and lastly, does this compromise your lifestyle. no not in the immediate event present or in the future. in the immediate event present, you attract better people and hence live a fuller life (maybe with a little lesser cash), and grow it into profits sooner than any projected break-evens.

i could go on like this forever, but somehow i believe that this all the knowledge i have currently to make money out of. and hence let me be a little modest and prudent and make some money for a change. so all the best to you, the entrepreneur. do good and get more than good from a lot of happy buyers in the near and distant future.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

why is the obvious rejected?

today i pitched for the advertising business of a mattress manufacturer. the problems are aplenty. consider this. there are about 4 serious brands followed by 230 odd in delhi alone. the product is pretty generic. there are some 8 combinations. foam, coir, sandwich foam and coir, springs, and the above with covers and quilts. thickness is already industry standard, so are the dimensions in length and breadth. some technology exists in designing ortho positive mattresses and in using modern inputs like memory foam. but again, there is hardly anything to differentiate brands on

so, all advertising in the category looks the same, a semi-clad or covered woman on a mattress with an inviting look on her face. that seems to suggest 'not sleeping' instead of sleeping.

given this, the task is to create recall and market leadership. usage situations are the same. purchase behavior is unique to the category. despite being an evolved industry (in product terms, with very little innovation happening), brands serve as reassurance of quality alone. and to add complexity to the story, quality is wrongly understood as durability, thickness, stiffness and material of the fabric used to cover the mattress. how do we progress?

further consumption analysis points that while sleeping is the primary usage situation, good sleep is not attributed to the quality, life or efficiency of the mattress at all. but bad sleep is loosely identified with a sagging or bent mattresses. even then, a change is not called for.

to cut a long story short, any and every mattress therefore needs a tighter association with good sleep and needs to do this with some ownership in the space. it can possibly own comfort, support or care (a mixture of both). these can easily be tied into product values like porosity and ability to absorb sweat, fibre strength, and balance of layers. keeping this in mind, i proposed that the brand build an obvious emotional bridge. that of reassurance. of usage and its result, good sleep.

magically, this space is still available. nobody seems to have seen the gap of product delivery reassurance on an everyday basis. and thereby breifing creative on the lines of 'whenever you think of sleep or you want to sleep, think of the brand'. somehow, we did not connect as the team on the other side was expecting a radical shift in communication. like hard rock and good sleep. as the new heady combination that will win the youth to the brand. that could be a plausible route. but what amazes me is the sheer non-acceptance of the obvious.

just because good sleep is seen as a benefit and accepted as a benefit by one and all, is the block against the bridge. isn't it surprising then that consumers and everyday users never recall the mattress as a primary contributor to good sleep that they enjoy. familiarity not only breeds contempt but also blinds even brilliant minds. something similar had happened earlier in another pitch, another client and another situation. thankfully, there the team woke up to the fresh perspective on the oft beaten or trodden path. it was a new tv channel. and i told them that content sells. not names or propositions. because we as consumers buy content, remember characters and tune in for the limited hours that we spare for unwinding or entertainment. again the obvious. thankfully, bought. but surprising some large and established competitors differed. or did not reach the same conclusion. i am positive, even such competent teams would have eliminated the obvious in their attempts to be insightful and creative or strategic.

so, if you come across this page at random, and liked reading this note or ranting, but feel party to the crime; then i would like to remind you of sir arthur conan doyle, a character called sherlock holmes and the only instance where his intelligence was thwarted. in a bohemian way, the lady ensured to file away royal memoirs in the most obvious of all stowe-aways. because that is the last place even such a mind would look! so take heart, and next time be conscious enough to encourage even the obvious!

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

carbon

this funny thing called carbon offsets. if i were to fly down to LA from New Delhi, there is a calculator available at several sites that tells me how much i am contributing to ghg. and then i can visit some smart exchanges and buy green energy or effort to cancel it. wow.

listen guys, this is crap. being rich is not a privilege as far as planet earth is concerned. it does not understand money. it only understands a delicate balance. so we clearly need to build when we stretch resources. and all of us have to contribute. we cant get away by paying some other person some dollars. to do what we should have done in the first place.

conceptually, lets understand it that we all are equals. and the responsibility is equal. and we need to start from where we are today. indifferent to the past that has been. for instance, if we have been using coal for a century, we need to write that off, and start with other renewable and alternate sources from today. this may mean a loss in production, higher costs and losses in the short run but its worth it if it yields a better tomorrow to our sons and daughters. and the economics do work out. lets take into account the present value of all the profits made in the century. enough right. but thats just an equation. lets see where the economics makes sense. consider 3 people in the equation. X, Y and Z. x does need to travel and buys credits worth 79$. he pays to Y to use a solar heater and gets the satisfaction of the offset. but Y uses the extra funds to buy a better house. Uh oh, so much more cement got made, so much more power is going to be used. so Y delegates the action to Z to be able to generate higher profits for himself. Z is unfortunately the poorest who does not have the access to other basic necessities. result, he uses solar for hot water, but gets money and invests in necessities of urban living. like convenience foods. uh oh, we seem to have successfully introduced 2 new consumers to high ghg generating businesses. and this cycle goes on. earth does not get the money or the resoruces or the adaptations to rejuvenate itself. see where i am leading to.

but is there a solution to this. X does need to fly.

the solutions lie in working on current status. we need to build engines that will take us flying on alternate fuels. we need to build more energy efficient air craft. we need to build efficient capacities. not beds, because they use more energy per capita. and please guys, can we look at carbon fibre. to build. fuel can also be saved on better traffic management.

the list develops. and the start has to be made where there are resources. it will be better if instead of offsets, the rich can buy investments into change in their own environment and space first. so how can about quasi government bonds and financial instruments that can ensure change in industry while maintaining a baisc return to shareholders?