Wednesday, September 19, 2007

carbon

this funny thing called carbon offsets. if i were to fly down to LA from New Delhi, there is a calculator available at several sites that tells me how much i am contributing to ghg. and then i can visit some smart exchanges and buy green energy or effort to cancel it. wow.

listen guys, this is crap. being rich is not a privilege as far as planet earth is concerned. it does not understand money. it only understands a delicate balance. so we clearly need to build when we stretch resources. and all of us have to contribute. we cant get away by paying some other person some dollars. to do what we should have done in the first place.

conceptually, lets understand it that we all are equals. and the responsibility is equal. and we need to start from where we are today. indifferent to the past that has been. for instance, if we have been using coal for a century, we need to write that off, and start with other renewable and alternate sources from today. this may mean a loss in production, higher costs and losses in the short run but its worth it if it yields a better tomorrow to our sons and daughters. and the economics do work out. lets take into account the present value of all the profits made in the century. enough right. but thats just an equation. lets see where the economics makes sense. consider 3 people in the equation. X, Y and Z. x does need to travel and buys credits worth 79$. he pays to Y to use a solar heater and gets the satisfaction of the offset. but Y uses the extra funds to buy a better house. Uh oh, so much more cement got made, so much more power is going to be used. so Y delegates the action to Z to be able to generate higher profits for himself. Z is unfortunately the poorest who does not have the access to other basic necessities. result, he uses solar for hot water, but gets money and invests in necessities of urban living. like convenience foods. uh oh, we seem to have successfully introduced 2 new consumers to high ghg generating businesses. and this cycle goes on. earth does not get the money or the resoruces or the adaptations to rejuvenate itself. see where i am leading to.

but is there a solution to this. X does need to fly.

the solutions lie in working on current status. we need to build engines that will take us flying on alternate fuels. we need to build more energy efficient air craft. we need to build efficient capacities. not beds, because they use more energy per capita. and please guys, can we look at carbon fibre. to build. fuel can also be saved on better traffic management.

the list develops. and the start has to be made where there are resources. it will be better if instead of offsets, the rich can buy investments into change in their own environment and space first. so how can about quasi government bonds and financial instruments that can ensure change in industry while maintaining a baisc return to shareholders?

No comments: